If you own the Gale Force Nine edition of Dune, a lot of what you see in the box started life as fan art. Around 2010, Ilya Baranovsky, Ilya77 on BoardGameGeek, redrew the whole 1979 game and shared it as a free print-and-play. Groups printed it and played it for years. The MCDM video that got me into Dune was played on one of those print-and-plays. I wrote about that video in Why Dune?.
When Gale Force Nine remade the game in 2019, they contracted with Ilya for the rights to his art. The look most of us now think of as Dune came from one fan making something for other fans.
Dune Zone uses AI to make images. I’m not trying to hide that, and I’m not trying to take anyone’s work or break any laws. So here is what I do, what the law says about it, and who made what.
The community kept building
Ilya’s art didn’t stop at the printer or the box. Players built Tabletop Simulator mods, online versions and whole new factions on top of it. I built a few of those mods myself, which I wrote about in the Tabletop Simulator post.
That work was never licensed. This whole community exists because the people who own Dune let it exist. That’s the Herbert family and Herbert Properties, Gale Force Nine, the original designers Bill Eberle, Jack Kittredge and Peter Olotka, and the artists, Ilya first among them.
Thank you to every one of them, from the bottom of my heart. All I want is for this community to grow, with more people playing this amazing board game.
Why I use AI
I want to build the best tool I possibly can, and that needs new images that fit. A homebrew faction of space orks shouldn’t have Duncan Idaho as one of its leaders. Borrowed portraits make a faction feel unfinished, and the same goes for its emblem. Every new faction needs its own leaders, emblem and decals, and they should look right next to the originals.
I don’t have the drawing skills to make those, or the time. Letting everyone upload their own images isn’t the answer either. I couldn’t moderate every upload. AI fills that gap.
What it actually does
“AI art” covers a lot of different things, so here are the four ways it’s used on Dune Zone, from closest to the original to furthest away.
Editing. Some GF9 portraits only exist printed on a token, with a rim and a number on top. AI removes those so the portrait can sit in a new frame. The result is still GF9’s image, and it’s credited that way.
Redrawing. Duke Leto’s portrait is redrawn from GF9’s own render in their KH edition announcement, matched to the other Atreides leaders. It’s still based on GF9’s picture.
New subjects. The Hivers are a homebrew faction of insect-like aliens created and drawn by AloeWing. Together with their friend Roxsy-Variant, we brought those drawings into the GF9 look, and we have permission to use them as open source.
New marks. Emblems and decals for homebrew factions, designed here and traced into clean vector shapes.
EditingGF9's art, token rim removed
RedrawingRedrawn from GF9's own render
New subjectsAn artist's drawing, brought into the GF9 look- New marksAn emblem designed here, traced to vectors
What the law says
I’m not a lawyer, but from my research, in both the US and the EU nobody can own a style. An individual drawing is protected. The way it’s drawn is not: the ink lines, the colors, the mood.
So a new portrait drawn in the style of Ilya’s leaders is a new image. A copy of one of his portraits, cleaned up or slightly changed, still belongs to the original author. There’s no magic percentage that turns one into the other. What counts is whether you can still recognize the original drawing.
AI doesn’t change that test. Whether an image copies another is judged on how it looks, not on the tool that made it. One thing does differ. In the US, a court decided that an image made purely by AI has no copyright owner at all (Thaler v. Perlmutter).
About the training data
People argue over whether “an image made purely by AI” even makes sense as a statement. AI models were trained on artists’ work without asking. Courts in the US and Europe are still working out if that was legal. I think that if the law says artists should be paid for it, they should be.
I’ll wait for the courts, but until then I’ll keep using the tool, because it makes what I need. If you’re an artist and you see an image on Dune Zone that you recognize as your work, please email me at support@dune.zone. If you ask, I’ll remove it or credit you properly (your choice).
None of this is simple. Something can be within the law and still cross a line for a lot of people, because there are morals beyond the law. I try to do the right thing. For me, banning all AI use isn’t the answer, but I respect people who see it differently.
So, whose work do we credit?
Someone asked me exactly this on a forum. Here’s the answer:
- GF9’s art, including versions of it edited with AI: Ilya Baranovsky, Solveig Reda and Lochen Reda, published by Gale Force Nine.
- New portraits in that style: AI-assisted, in Ilya’s style, plus whoever came up with the character or drew the sketch. For the ones I generated, I’d release them into the public domain if no artist claims them as theirs.
- Community sets: the people who made them, by name.
- Emblems and decals made here: Dune Zone. For the ones I generated, I’d release them into the public domain if no artist claims them as theirs.
What changed while writing this
Writing this post made me look hard at everything on the site. After some reflection, I removed some leader portraits that were based on characters from other video games.
I’ve also worked on showing the credits and sources of every image on Dune Zone. You can see them in the media gallery. I’m just one person, so if you see any mistakes, please let me know and I’ll fix them.
That meant going through about two thousand images and tracing where each one first appeared and who drew it. It isn’t finished. Around 250 are still marked as found online while I look for their original artist.
ur-director-malina-aru.pngArt by Solveig Reda for Dune: CHOAM & Richese (Gale Force Nine, 2021), edited with AI image tools to remove the token rim and badges.
duke-leto.pngMade with AI image tools, based on a Duke Leto render from Gale Force Nine's new-edition announcement, in the style of Ilya Baranovsky's Atreides portraits.
hiver-amber-pendant.pngMade with AI image tools, based on drawings by AloeWing, who created the Hivers, in the style of the GF9 Dune leader portraits.These are the rules I will keep to:
- Credit the original artists.
- Keep a record of how every image was made.
- Don’t pass off a copy as something new.
- Keep Dune Zone free and unofficial.
- Take an image down if its owner asks.
Artists, you're invited
The Hivers show how I’d like this to work. AloeWing created and drew them, and Roxsy-Variant and I worked together to make them fit the Dune look. The art is still AloeWing’s, and we have permission to use it as open source.
If you draw, that’s an open invitation. I’ll add your artwork to Dune Zone with your name on it. If you’d like, I’ll help you fit it to the art style.
One last thing. Whatever you think of AI, the person using it to build something is still a person. Let’s be kind to each other about it, even when we don’t agree.





